Great question — Consumer Proposals and Debt Management Plans (DMPs) are both tools to help people get out of debt, but they are very different in how they work, how they affect your credit, and who qualifies.
Let’s break it down side by side to help you decide.
| Feature | Consumer Proposal | Debt Management Plan (DMP) |
|---|---|---|
| What is it? | A legal process under federal law that reduces your debt (you only pay part of what you owe) | An informal agreement to repay 100% of your debt, but often with reduced interest |
| Who manages it? | A Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) | A Credit Counselling Agency |
| How much do you repay? | Typically 30–60% of your total debt (rest is forgiven) | 100% of your debt — but often with 0% or reduced interest |
| Monthly payment | Lower than your current one (based on what you can afford) | May be similar to what you're paying now, just with no or lower interest |
| Interest | Frozen immediately | Usually lowered or eliminated (e.g., credit cards may go to 0%) |
| Credit impact | Serious: R7 rating on credit report for 3 years after completion | Moderate: R7 rating during repayment (removed 2 years after completion) |
| Legal protection | Yes — creditors must stop collections and lawsuits | No legal protection — voluntary, so creditors can opt out |
| Time to complete | Up to 5 years | Usually 3–5 years |
| Includes CRA/tax debt? | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Includes student loans? | ✅ Yes (if over 7 years old) | ❌ No |
Here’s how to decide:
- You can’t realistically repay the full amount you owe
- You want legal protection from creditors
- You have CRA debt or old student loans
- You want a fresh start and lower monthly payments
- You can afford to repay 100% of the debt with some interest relief
- Your debts are mostly high-interest credit cards
- You want to avoid legal proceedings
- Your credit is still in decent shape and you want to protect it more
- You owe $58,000+
- Most of it is high-interest credit card debt (13.99%–26.99%)
- You're currently paying about $805/month
- You already have a low-interest LOC (7.44%) available
- You're considering consolidation
➡️ A Debt Management Plan may not save you that much, since you already have a lower-interest option (the LOC) and can avoid paying 100% of the debt at full price.
➡️ A Consumer Proposal could be useful if your LOC isn’t an option anymore (maxed out, closed, or unaffordable) — and you can’t keep up.
- If you still qualify for your LOC, use it to consolidate and pay aggressively (e.g. $800–$1000/month).
- If that’s no longer realistic — talk to a Licensed Insolvency Trustee for a free consultation about a Consumer Proposal.
- A Debt Management Plan is probably your least effective option here (since it still repays 100% of the debt).
(I told it about Line of Credit increase but it would increase interest rate)
Thanks — this new info changes the picture quite a bit. Let's walk through what this means and re-evaluate whether it's better to:
- Expand your Line of Credit (LOC) at 11.99% to consolidate everything, or
- Consider a Consumer Proposal, or
- Stick with your current payments and LOC.
| Monthly Payment | Time to Payoff | Total Interest Paid |
|---|---|---|
| $800 | ~9 years (108 months) | ~$47,000 |
| $900 | ~7.5 years (91 months) | ~$39,000 |
| $1,000 | ~6.5 years (79 months) | ~$33,000 |
If you stay with your:
- 13.99% Visa ($15K)
- 26.99% Tim's & Walmart ($17.8K combined)
- 7.44% LOC ($24.7K)
... and pay $805/month, you’ll still likely:
- Take 15–17 years to pay it all off
- Pay $90,000–$100,000+ in total interest
So, even the 11.99% consolidated LOC saves you money and time if you can afford to pay $800–$1,000/month.
Let’s assume a Licensed Insolvency Trustee negotiates a proposal where you repay ~40% of your $58,000 balance = $23,200.
| Monthly Payment | Time to Payoff | Interest | Credit Rating Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| ~$387 | 60 months (5 years) | $0 (interest is frozen) | R7 for 3 years after completion |
➡️ If approved, you’d save ~$35,000 in principal and all interest. ➡️ The tradeoff: your credit score drops (temporarily), and it shows as a public record.
| Option | Total Cost | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expand LOC to 11.99% | ~$80K (with $800–$900/mo payments) | Keeps credit score, simple repayment | Higher interest than ideal, long payoff |
| Consumer Proposal | ~$23K–$30K | Huge savings, frozen interest, fixed term | Credit hit (R7), legal filing |
| Do nothing | $100K+ | No changes | Highest cost, years of stress |
If:
- You can’t get a low-interest consolidation loan
- And you want a clean, affordable, fast way out
👉 A Consumer Proposal is likely your best move.
It’s the only path that:
- Slashes your debt
- Stops interest immediately
- Gives you a fixed monthly payment and debt-free date